Season 1 (2007)

7.28 avg 52 episodes 6.6 → 7.8 11 min avg

Season 1 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Transformers: The Movie Review	6.6	186
2	Drug Cartoon Special	7.5	154
3	Cloverfield Trailer Review	6.1	132
4	Power Rangers: A Look Back	6.9	146
5	Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Launch	7.0	115
6	Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles	7.1	133
7	Top 11 Scariest Nostalgic Moments	7.3	126
8	Super Mario Bros.: The Movie	7.6	154
9	Cloverfield	6.3	121
10	Street Fighter and Mortal Kombat: The Movie Reviews - Part 1	7.5	133
11	Street Fighter and Mortal Kombat: The Movie Reviews - Part 2	7.5	138
12	Space Jam	7.2	190
13	Angry Video Game Nerd Rant	6.4	104
14	Angry Video Game Nerd Rant: Part 2	7.0	104
15	Pokemon the Movie	7.0	159
16	AVGN Wizard Rant	7.1	94
17	The Wizard	7.8	140
18	Top 11 Naughtiest Moments in Animaniacs	7.4	115
19	Batman and Robin	8.9	331
20	Top 11 Catchiest Theme Songs	7.4	107
21	90's Sports Montage	6.9	90
22	AVGN Response... Response	6.6	94
23	Top 11 Drug PSAs	7.7	108
24	The Battle of Epic Proportions	7.3	91
25	Captain Planet	7.7	131
26	Double Dare	7.1	94
27	3 Ninjas	6.8	101
28	Top 11 Hottest Animated Women	6.4	108
29	Video Game Review	7.6	116
30	The Search for the Nostalgia Chick	5.2	79
31	He-Man and the Masters of the Universe	7.2	101
32	Follow That Bird	6.6	102
33	Saved by the Bell	7.4	106
34	Tom and Jerry: The Movie	8.3	204
35	Top 11 Saddest Nostalgic Moments	7.3	103
36	Nostalgia Chick Winner!	6.0	73
37	Surf Ninjas	7.5	96
38	NC vs. AVGN Showdown	7.4	90
39	Top 11 Nostalgic Animated Shows	7.6	91
40	Kazaam	8.0	150
41	AVGN vs. NC Final Battle	8.0	107
42	Drew Struzan Tribute	7.5	72
43	Halloween '08 Special	7.0	91
44	Double Dragon	7.3	97
45	Top 11 Underrated Nostalgia Classics	7.7	103
46	Howard the Duck	7.6	144
47	Mortal Kombat: Annihilation	7.9	155
48	Godzilla	7.9	153
49	Top 11 Disney Villains	7.8	105
50	Super Mario Brothers Super Show	7.7	105
51	Top 12 Greatest Christmas Specials	7.9	94
52	Jingle All the Way	7.8	146

Season 2 (2009)

7.54 avg 55 episodes 7.2 → 7.5 19 min avg

Season 2 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Nicktoons	7.2	112
2	Nickcoms	7.3	96
3	Snick	7.3	88
4	Good Burger	7.7	142
5	FernGully: The Last Rainforest	7.4	117
6	A Kid in King Arthur's Court	7.7	110
7	The Good Son	6.8	111
8	Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog	7.8	145
9	Top 11 Nostalgic Mindfucks	8.0	116
10	Twister	7.3	108
11	The Garbage Pail Kids Movie	8.4	166
12	Rock-A-Doodle	7.3	109
13	Titanic: The Animated Movie	8.5	187
14	The Pagemaster	7.0	118
15	The NeverEnding Story	7.1	93
16	Moonwalker	7.4	111
17	Top 11 Dumbest Superman Moments	7.6	97
18	TMNT	7.0	104
19	Red Sonja	7.1	88
20	TGWTG Team Brawl, 1st Anniversary Video	7.4	91
21	Short Circuit 1 and 2	7.3	89
22	Old vs. New: Batman vs. the Dark Knight	7.3	118
23	Full House	7.0	115
24	North	8.3	136
25	Critic and Nerd: TMNT Making of Coming Out of Their Shells	8.5	138
26	Sidekicks	7.6	88
27	Gargoyles	7.3	92
28	Transformers 2	6.8	86
29	Steel	7.8	106
30	Top 11 Cereal Mascots	7.5	74
31	Barb Wire	7.4	93
32	Old vs. New: LOTR Animated vs. Lord of the Rings	7.8	113
33	Last Action Hero	6.4	128
34	Captain N: The Game Master	7.8	82
35	We're Back! A Dinosaur Story	7.5	101
36	Warriors of Virtue	7.4	79
37	Captain America	7.6	117
38	Top 11 Nostalgia Critic Fuckups	7.9	97
39	Alone in the Dark	8.4	149
40	Blank Check	7.4	98
41	Old vs. New: Willy Wonka	7.4	125
42	Cool as Ice	7.9	100
43	Suburban Commando	8.2	109
44	The Next Karate Kid	7.6	89
45	Casper	7.6	138
46	Superman IV	7.8	120
47	Congo	7.5	87
48	A Tribute to Siskel and Ebert	8.2	127
49	Judge Dredd	7.6	106
50	Tank Girl	6.8	92
51	Jack Frost	7.0	105
52	He-Man and She-Ra: A Christmas Special	7.4	81
53	Return of the Christmas Specials	7.7	75
54	The Star Wars Holiday Special	8.4	169
55	Ernest Saves Christmas	7.5	95

Season 3 (2010)

7.46 avg 58 episodes 7.8 → 7.4 20 min avg

Season 3 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Commando	7.8	115
2	Junior	7.4	129
3	Conan: Part 1	7.6	87
4	Conan: Part 2	7.5	84
5	End of Days	7.3	95
6	The 100th Episode: Battlefield Earth	8.6	172
7	Bebe's Kids	7.4	89
8	Lost in Space	7.8	94
9	Top 11 Villain Songs	7.8	94
10	Quest for Camelot	7.9	124
11	Old vs. New: The Nutty Professor	7.7	81
12	Bio-Dome	8.0	133
13	The NeverEnding Story II: The Next Chapter	7.5	112
14	Top 11 Most Awkward Christopher Walken Moments	7.9	94
15	Flubber	7.3	111
16	Home Alone 3	7.3	120
17	'Ask That Guy' Violates Ma-Ti	4.6	64
18	Old vs. New: King Kong	7.1	87
19	Drop Dead Fred	7.3	107
20	The Care Bears Movie	7.5	96
21	Kickassia Part 1: The Withering Eye	7.1	87
22	Kickassia Part 2: Triumph and Treacle	6.9	79
23	Kickassia Part 3: Inglorious Glory	7.2	79
24	Kickassia Part 4: The Beginning of the End of the Beginning	6.9	82
25	Kickassia Part 5: The Fall of the Risen	7.3	82
26	Kickassia Part 6: All the Really Bad Shit Happens	7.3	79
27	Jaws 3D	8.0	115
28	Free Willy	6.9	92
29	A Troll in Central Park	7.6	109
30	Theodore Rex	7.2	95
31	Top 11 Coolest Cliches	7.4	83
32	Hook	7.3	104
33	Independence Day	7.5	113
34	The Room	9.3	424
35	The Tommy Wiseau Show	8.2	116
36	The Phantom	6.8	78
37	Zeus and Roxanne	7.7	74
38	Animaniacs Tribute	8.0	84
39	The Flintstones Movie	6.7	111
40	Mr. Nanny	7.1	81
41	Rocky IV	7.3	102
42	Chairman of the Board	7.0	80
43	The Next Top 11 Nostalgia Critic Fuckups	7.9	98
44	Pound Puppies and the Legend of Big Paw	7.2	79
45	The Pebble and the Penguin	6.9	89
46	Ernest Scared Stupid	7.6	82
47	Top 11 Scariest Performances	7.7	92
48	It	7.8	156
49	Leprechaun	7.5	99
50	My Pet Monster	7.5	81
51	Nostalgic Commercials	8.7	141
52	Old vs. New: 10 Commandments vs. Prince of Egypt	7.6	76
53	Thief and the Cobbler	7.5	101
54	Waterworld	7.2	93
55	Little Monsters	7.3	85
56	Rover Dangerfield	7.6	86
57	You're a Rotten Dirty Bastard: Christmas Special	7.3	90
58	The First Couple: TMNT	7.4	80

Season 4 (2011)

7.38 avg 55 episodes 8.6 → 7.3 22 min avg

Rollercoaster

Season 4 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	The NeverEnding Story III	8.6	191
2	Ferngully 2	7.2	89
3	Secret of NIMH 2	8.1	107
4	Care Bears 2	7.7	92
5	Dungeons and Dragons	7.6	106
6	Top 11 Dumbest Spiderman Moments	7.6	118
7	The Lost World: Jurassic Park	6.9	117
8	Return of the Nostalgic Commercials	8.6	127
9	Inspector Gadget	7.7	141
10	Old vs. New: The Karate Kid	7.3	89
11	The Langoliers	8.0	122
12	Airborne	7.1	76
13	Baby Geniuses	7.4	133
14	The X-Men Cartoon	7.6	87
15	The Magic Voyage	7.4	100
16	Double Team	7.5	83
17	Top 11 Dumbasses in Distress	8.0	108
18	Jaws 4: The Revenge	8.0	118
19	Gordy	8.0	107
20	The Other Animated Titanic Movie	9.1	215
21	Revenge of the Commercials	8.4	119
22	Once Upon a Forest	6.9	84
23	Little Nemo	6.8	83
24	Old vs. New: True Grit	7.3	77
25	Suburban Knights: Part I	7.6	82
26	Suburban Knights: Part II	6.9	67
27	Suburban Knights: Part III	7.0	68
28	Suburban Knights: Part IV	6.6	65
29	Suburban Knights: Part V	6.6	68
30	Suburban Knights: Part VI	6.9	71
31	Suburban Knights: Part VII	7.1	76
32	Transformers 3 Review	6.7	75
33	Milk Money	7.5	90
34	Rad	7.3	70
35	Duck Tales	7.5	80
36	The Care Bears Adventure in Wonderland	7.5	77
37	Cop and 1/2	7.4	73
38	Top 11 Batman: TAS Episodes	8.2	93
39	Alaska	7.1	72
40	Let's Play Bart's Nightmare	4.1	135
41	James and the Giant Peach	6.8	114
42	The Avengers	6.9	94
43	Simon Sez	6.7	74
44	The Tommyknockers	7.5	87
45	The Haunting	7.4	105
46	Blair Witch 2: Book of Shadows	7.4	98
47	Exorcist 2	7.1	75
48	Doug's 1st Movie	7.7	122
49	The Cell	6.9	83
50	Superman: The Animated Series	7.2	80
51	Felix the Cat: The Movie	7.6	114
52	Moulin Rouge	8.3	165
53	Babes in Toyland	7.0	69
54	The Grinch	7.4	132
55	Child's Play	7.3	108

Season 5 (2012)

6.98 avg 38 episodes 7.2 → 7.1 24 min avg

Season 5 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Santa Claus: The Movie	7.2	83
2	Star Trek: The Motion Picture	7.3	97
3	Star Trek III: The Search for Spock	6.7	90
4	Star Trek V: The Final Frontier	7.0	86
5	Star Trek: Generations	7.0	82
6	Star Trek: Insurrection	7.1	80
7	Patch Adams	7.9	136
8	Ponyo	6.6	101
9	Dunston Checks In	6.6	79
10	Thomas and the Magic Railroad	7.4	102
11	The Top 11 Nostalgia Critic Fuck-ups: Part 3	7.7	82
12	Ri¢hie Ri¢h	7.1	95
13	Jungle 2 Jungle	6.4	91
14	Old vs New - Manhunter and Red Dragon	7.4	66
15	Starchaser: The Legend of Orin	6.8	73
16	Raiders of the Story Arc: Transformers	6.3	64
17	A Simple Wish	7.8	114
18	Alien: Resurrection	7.4	102
19	Jack	7.4	95
20	Heavy Metal	6.7	68
21	Mr. Magoo	7.1	79
22	Top 11 Simpsons Episodes	8.2	106
23	Signs	7.6	109
24	Digimon the Movie	6.7	100
25	The Top 11 Awesome Movie Themes	7.7	78
26	Superbabies: Baby Geniuses 2	6.1	105
27	Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom	6.5	109
28	The Wiz	6.6	81
29	Total Recall	7.0	89
30	Scooby-Doo	7.9	161
31	To Boldly Flee: Part I	6.6	63
32	To Boldly Flee: Part II	6.6	60
33	To Boldly Flee: Part III	6.3	61
34	To Boldly Flee: Part IV	6.4	66
35	To Boldly Flee: Part V	6.2	61
36	To Boldly Flee: Part VI	6.3	59
37	To Boldly Flee: Part VII	6.6	61
38	To Boldly Flee: Part VIII	7.1	64

Season 6 (2013)

7.30 avg 48 episodes 8.0 → 7.1 23 min avg

Rollercoaster

Season 6 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	The Odd Life of Timothy Green	8.0	160
2	Is Twilight the Worst Thing Ever?	7.6	103
3	Pearl Harbor	7.8	150
4	Does Romeo and Juliet Suck?	6.7	81
5	Son of the Mask	8.4	218
6	What the F**K Was Up with Where the Wild Things Are?	7.5	80
7	The King and I	7.2	103
8	What's with the Princess Hate?	6.9	77
9	Catwoman	7.5	148
10	Farewell to Roger Ebert	8.3	110
11	The Looney Tunes Show: Good or Bad?	7.1	103
12	The Cat in the Hat	8.0	195
13	Did Seinfeld Lie to Us?	6.9	73
14	Top 11 South Park Episodes	7.8	107
15	Is Parody Dead?	7.8	120
16	Jurassic Park	7.3	113
17	Why Is Loki So Hot?	5.8	85
18	A.I: Artificial Intelligence	7.3	132
19	Are Video Games Art?	7.2	85
20	Master of Disguise	7.8	141
21	What Does the Secret of NIMH Mean?	6.9	72
22	Turbo: A Power Rangers Movie	7.5	131
23	Are Superheroes Whiny Little Bitches?	6.6	72
24	Top 11 Dumbest Lord of the Rings Moments	7.0	110
25	Is it Right to Nitpick?	7.2	63
26	Was Batman Season 4 Hit or Miss?	6.6	69
27	Sailor Moon	5.8	126
28	Why Is Tom and Jerry Genius?	7.3	84
29	Les Misérables: Musical Review	7.5	112
30	Nostalgia Critic's Top 11 Adult Jokes We Never Got as Kids	6.7	82
31	The Last Airbender	8.5	195
32	WTF Is with the Ending of the Graduate?	6.9	62
33	Bridge to Terabithia	7.6	115
34	Is the Big Lebowski a Masterpiece?	7.1	75
35	The Shining Mini-Series	7.9	133
36	Why Do We Love Zombies?	6.7	71
37	Sharknado	6.8	115
38	Should We Scare the S#*% Out of Kids?	6.9	72
39	Devil	7.6	104
40	How Come Super Mario Comics Don't Suck?	7.1	61
41	Dawn of the Commercials	8.3	125
42	Has CGI Gone Too Far?	7.0	77
43	Man of Steel	7.5	129
44	Top 12 Santa Clauses	7.5	74
45	Eight Crazy Nights	7.8	136
46	Why Lie About Santa?	5.8	63
47	The Worst Christmas Special Ever!	8.5	164
48	Why Is Arthur Christmas a Masterpiece?	7.1	64

Season 7 (2014)

7.28 avg 51 episodes 7.9 → 7.9 22 min avg

Rollercoaster

Season 7 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Face/Off	7.9	139
2	When Is Something So Bad It's Good?	6.8	78
3	The Wicker Man	8.3	143
4	Ghost Rider	7.6	116
5	Top 11 Strangest (Yet Best) Couples	7.4	66
6	Ghost Dad	7.4	106
7	When Is a Movie Just a Movie?	6.6	67
8	Are You Sick of "Let It Go?"	7.0	81
9	Alice in Wonderland	7.6	132
10	Top 11 Things You Never Noticed About Ghostbusters	6.6	67
11	Disney Afternoon	8.1	109
12	What You Never Knew About Batman	6.8	75
13	Foodfight!	8.5	214
14	Top 11 GOOD Things from the Star Wars Prequels	7.6	100
15	The Swan Princess	7.3	98
16	What You Never Knew About Roger Rabbit	7.2	78
17	The Lorax	7.8	137
18	Why Do We Love Stupid?	6.9	79
19	Old vs New - Spider-Man	6.3	129
20	Is Juno Any Damn Good?	6.4	67
21	Blues Brothers 2000	7.3	99
22	What You Never Knew About Gremlins	6.8	62
23	Jurassic Park III	7.3	110
24	After Earth	7.7	114
25	Nostalgia Critic Talks Transformers 4	6.8	81
26	Is Tree of Life Full of Shit?	6.5	60
27	BloodRayne	8.2	123
28	What You Never Knew About Hot Fuzz	7.1	80
29	The Purge	7.6	110
30	Top 11 Best Film Trailers	7.3	73
31	Small Soldiers	6.5	121
32	What You Never Knew About Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles	6.9	67
33	The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement	7.9	97
34	Does "American Beauty" Still Hold Up?	6.3	64
35	Ghost Rider 2: Spirit of Vengeance	7.3	93
36	Top 11 Worst Avatar Episodes	7.3	66
37	Top 11 Best Avatars	8.0	87
38	Is Eyes Wide Shut Just Artsy Porn?	6.2	68
39	Maximum Overdrive	7.1	108
40	Top 11 New Halloween Classics	7.3	74
41	Monster Squad	7.8	91
42	Is Sleepy Hollow Secretly Brilliant?	6.9	68
43	Rise of the Commercials	8.5	125
44	Is There Another Good Shyamalan Movie?	6.9	66
45	Forest Warrior	6.8	83
46	What You Never Knew About Planes, Trains & Automobiles	6.8	61
47	Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer	7.9	115
48	Overlooked Christmas Specials	7.4	64
49	A Christmas Story 2	7.7	104
50	What You Never Knew About Christmas Vacation	7.2	57
51	Care Bears Nutcracker Suite	7.9	88

Season 8 (2015)

6.90 avg 48 episodes 6.8 → 6.8 20 min avg

Rollercoaster

Season 8 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	The Matrix	6.8	147
2	The Animatrix	7.1	91
3	Matrix Reloaded	7.2	104
4	Matrix Revolutions	7.0	106
5	Did Tom and Jerry Kill Themselves?	6.5	92
6	Mamma Mia!	7.1	101
7	Can Hype Kill a Good Movie?	6.7	73
8	The Haunted Mansion	7.2	103
9	Why Is Nothing Original Anymore?	6.4	84
10	Daredevil	6.8	111
11	The Plot to Frozen 2	5.6	81
12	Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2014	7.8	125
13	The Dark Age of Movies	6.9	95
14	Demolition Man	7.8	101
15	Top 11 Animaniacs Episodes	7.3	64
16	The Legend of Zorro	7.3	87
17	The Ewoks Cartoon	6.5	72
18	Fantastic Four	7.3	100
19	Wild West C.O.W. Boys of Moo Mesa	6.6	64
20	The Adventures of Sharkboy and Lavagirl	7.9	132
21	Small Wonder	7.0	73
22	Jupiter Ascending	7.6	101
23	Sam and Max: Freelance Police	6.2	65
24	Jurassic World	5.3	159
25	Top 11 TV Show Intros	7.1	76
26	Planet of the Apes	7.2	106
27	Osmosis Jones	6.7	96
28	Are Kids Shows Better NOW Than Ever?	6.8	93
29	Garfield the Movie	7.4	120
30	Pixels	6.6	129
31	Why Does Everyone Hate the Cable Guy?	6.5	80
32	The Smurfs	8.0	104
33	When Does a Joke Go Too Far?	7.2	81
34	Hammerman	7.2	74
35	Mad Max: Fury Road	6.4	124
36	Did You Miss the Most Shocking Film in Years?	6.8	63
37	Event Horizon	6.3	86
38	Should Found Footage Stop?	6.6	64
39	Children of the Corn	7.5	108
40	Top 11 Halloween Guilty Pleasures	7.0	74
41	Hocus Pocus	4.9	121
42	Why Do We Holiday Too Early?	5.8	55
43	Conquest of the Commercials	8.1	111
44	Dragon's Lair	7.2	93
45	We Wish You a Turtle Christmas	7.5	118
46	Is a Charlie Brown Christmas Overrated?	6.9	59
47	Christmas with the Kranks	6.8	102
48	Star Wars: The Force Awakens	6.8	122

Season 9 (2016)

7.14 avg 50 episodes 7.2 → 7.0 21 min avg

Rollercoaster

Season 9 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Why Do Good Directors Go Bad?	7.2	94
2	The Happening	8.0	120
3	Top 11 Funniest Shyamalan Moments	6.8	81
4	Lady in the Water	7.6	102
5	Tangled vs. Frozen	6.1	68
6	Labyrinth	7.4	84
7	Where's the Fair Use?	8.7	140
8	Spawn	7.2	94
9	Is Goofy Secretly Badass?	7.7	71
10	Cats & Dogs	7.2	93
11	Was the Mask Supposed to Be Gory?	7.0	68
12	The Phantom of the Opera	5.7	89
13	How Right Are Trailers?	7.1	74
14	The Adventures of Pluto Nash	6.9	85
15	Pinky, Elmyra & the Brain	6.5	66
16	Batman vs. Superman	7.9	139
17	When Are Critics Wrong?	7.6	96
18	Blade	7.0	80
19	Is This the Best Batman Movie?	7.5	73
20	Old vs. New: Cinderella	7.1	73
21	Is White Washing Really Still a Thing?	5.4	80
22	Spy Kids 3D: Game Over	7.1	96
23	Top 11 Disney Princess Conspiracies	6.8	66
24	Jem and the Holograms	7.7	95
25	The Grinch vs. The Cat in the Hat	6.3	58
26	Scooby Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed	7.2	100
27	How True Is Amadeus?	6.9	52
28	Alvin and the Chipmunks	7.6	116
29	Can a Film Be So Good It's Bad?	6.3	60
30	Ghostbusters (2016)	7.1	100
31	Teddy Ruxpin: The Live Action Series	6.1	58
32	Wild Wild West	6.6	86
33	All the Looney Tunes Movies	7.2	64
34	Is Weird the New Brilliant?	7.6	66
35	The THIRD Animated Titanic Movie	7.7	104
36	Does PG Mean Anything Anymore?	7.8	98
37	The Adventures of Rocky & Bullwinkle	7.6	101
38	Is Nightmare Before Christmas Really THAT Great?	5.8	53
39	Dreamcatcher	7.4	81
40	The Top 11 Gravity Falls Episodes	7.7	53
41	Freddy vs. Jason	7.1	92
42	Can an Ending Ruin a Film?	6.7	71
43	Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out of the Shadows	7.6	90
44	Was Tiny Toons Written by Kids?	6.3	50
45	Battle of the Commercials	8.7	127
46	Disney Sequels We Want	6.3	69
47	Inspector Gadget Saves Christmas	7.3	75
48	Top 12 Christmas Commercials	8.1	73
49	I'll Be Home for Christmas	7.8	90
50	Rogue One: A Star Wars Story	7.0	108

Season 10 (2017)

6.94 avg 51 episodes 7.2 → 6.6 23 min avg

Rollercoaster

Season 10 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	The Top 11 Best Movie Sequels	7.2	92
2	Alvin and the Chipmunks: The Squeakquel	7.0	97
3	The Top 11 Worst Movie Sequels	6.4	105
4	The Smurfs 2	7.5	92
5	Garfield: A Tail of Two Kitties	7.1	90
6	Why Do So Many Sequels Suck?	6.8	80
7	Cool World	7.6	102
8	What Happened to Great Disney Villains?	6.6	63
9	Old vs New: Evil Dead	5.9	89
10	Top 11 WTF Alternate Endings	7.1	83
11	Balto	7.1	94
12	Should Bad Singers Be Dubbed?	5.9	74
13	Fant4stic	7.3	106
14	Is This the Best Joker Death?	7.1	71
15	Clockstoppers	6.6	69
16	The WEIRDEST Jack and the Beanstalk	7.5	75
17	The Flintstones in Viva Rock Vegas	7.3	88
18	Nostalgia Critic Suicide Squad Trailer	4.2	58
19	Suicide Squad	7.1	122
20	Was the Killing Joke That Bad?	6.9	67
21	Was Family Guy Meant to Be a Kids' Show?	6.6	60
22	Alien vs. Predator	7.3	87
23	Transformers: The Last Knight	7.3	76
24	Wonder Woman	7.7	79
25	When Should Remakes Not Happen?	6.6	63
26	Norm of the North	6.1	134
27	Cats Don't Dance	7.2	76
28	Hulk	7.6	105
29	Tom and Jerry: Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory	7.8	112
30	Monkeybone	7.1	72
31	G.I. Joe: The Movie	6.6	58
32	The Sorcerer's Apprentice	7.3	80
33	DuckTales 2017	7.2	87
34	Eragon	7.0	78
35	Do Credits Suck Now?	6.2	56
36	Kangaroo Jack	7.2	88
37	A Goofy Movie	7.2	75
38	Green Lantern	7.2	77
39	Scary Godmother	6.9	67
40	It (2017)	7.5	105
41	Halloween (2007)	6.3	70
42	The Mummy	6.1	98
43	The Mummy (2017)	7.2	87
44	Dragonball Evolution	7.6	106
45	Bangarang	6.0	53
46	War of the Commercials	8.4	84
47	Super Mario Bros: the Anime	6.2	52
48	Rapsittie Street Kids: Believe in Santa	7.9	90
49	A Muppet Family Christmas	6.9	56
50	Home Alone 2: Lost in New York	7.0	91
51	Star Wars: The Last Jedi	6.6	91

Season 11 (2018)

6.77 avg 51 episodes 5.9 → 6.9 27 min avg

Season 11 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Mars Attacks!	5.9	81
2	Lara Croft: Tomb Raider	7.0	81
3	Top 11 GOOD Adam Sandler Movies	6.8	78
4	Yogi Bear	7.1	84
5	Horton Hears a Who	6.7	67
6	Batman Forever	7.4	91
7	Freakazoid!	7.1	59
8	Alvin and the Chipmunks: Chipwrecked	7.0	80
9	Maleficent	6.4	69
10	Alice Through the Looking Glass	6.9	74
11	The Jungle Book (2016)	5.3	76
12	Beauty and the Beast (2017)	7.2	87
13	Woody Woodpecker (2018)	7.0	81
14	Jack and Jill	5.6	81
15	An American Tail: Fievel Goes West	4.7	83
16	Starship Troopers	6.5	71
17	The Emoji Movie	6.1	77
18	Scooby Doo the Mystery Begins	7.2	67
19	The Boss Baby	6.9	64
20	The Spirit	6.8	64
21	Deadpool 2	4.5	103
22	Chicken Little	6.9	85
23	Angry Birds	7.3	68
24	Do The Bartman	6.3	62
25	Fox Kids	7.9	72
26	The Evolution of the Purge Movies	6.6	55
27	The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen	6.9	65
28	Bartok the Magnificent	6.6	53
29	Mission: Impossible II	7.1	63
30	Sonic the Hedgehog: The Movie	6.3	67
31	Doom	7.1	63
32	Rise of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles	6.7	43
33	Ghostbusters II	6.9	55
34	Old vs. New: Teen Titans vs. Teen Titans Go!	6.5	51
35	Freddy Got Fingered	7.5	75
36	Big Fat Liar	7.0	55
37	Fantastic 4 Rise of Silver Surfer	6.9	66
38	Grading Cartoon Show Intros	7.7	54
39	Sleepwalkers	7.0	59
40	Top 11 Stephen King Movies	7.2	55
41	Van Helsing	6.3	55
42	AvP Requiem	6.6	52
43	Rubber	6.5	64
44	The Powerpuff Girls Movie	6.9	52
45	Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom	6.9	68
46	A Wrinkle in Time	6.6	59
47	Escape from the Commercials	8.0	62
48	A Christmas Story Live	7.2	57
49	The Search for Santa Paws	7.1	51
50	The Most Hated Nutcracker Movie Ever Made	7.8	73
51	Elf Bowling: The Movie	6.9	54

Season 12 (2019)

6.63 avg 52 episodes 7.0 → 6.2 30 min avg

Rollercoaster

Season 12 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Max Payne	7.0	62
2	When Did Marvel Villains Get Good?	6.9	66
3	RoboCop (2014)	7.0	61
4	The History of the M&M Characters	7.3	58
5	Black Cauldron	7.0	68
6	Top 11 Funniest Siskel and Ebert Reviews	6.9	60
7	The Country Bears	7.3	66
8	Donnie Darko	6.6	69
9	X-Men: The Animated Series (With the Creators)	6.6	50
10	X-Men	6.8	79
11	X2: X-Men United	6.5	77
12	X-Men: The Last Stand	6.9	72
13	X-Men Origins: Wolverine	6.5	88
14	Best F(r)iends	6.9	71
15	Tom and Jerry & the Wizard of Oz	7.5	70
16	Hop	7.2	64
17	Stuart Little	6.9	62
18	Toonami	6.8	62
19	Balto II: Wolf Quest	6.7	51
20	Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within	7.1	53
21	Man on the Moon is BAD, Here's Why	6.0	62
22	Mary Poppins Returns	6.6	71
23	Movie 43	6.9	73
24	Alien³	6.8	69
25	Barney's Great Adventure	7.3	66
26	Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief	6.8	63
27	Constantine	5.4	53
28	Kim Possible	6.9	66
29	The Lion King	6.5	71
30	Blade II	6.5	49
31	Why Do Disney Remakes Keep Making Money?	7.3	62
32	That Darn Cat (1997)	7.2	60
33	The Jetsons Meet the Flintstones	7.1	52
34	Underworld	4.9	53
35	Mulan II	7.2	63
36	Alvin and the Chipmunks: The Road Chip	6.9	59
37	The Pest (1997)	6.9	53
38	The Wall	1.3	698
39	Aladdin (2019)	7.0	68
40	Hannibal	6.0	49
41	It Chapter Two	6.1	68
42	Demon Knight	5.8	38
43	Venom	7.1	62
44	Scooby-Doo on Zombie Island	5.7	45
45	Justice League	6.7	56
46	Frozen	6.6	56
47	Planet of the Commercials	7.7	75
48	Did Joker Imagine Batman?	7.1	53
49	The Grinch (2018)	6.9	53
50	The Most Insane Christmas Rom Com	6.2	36
51	Santa Clause 3: The Escape Clause	7.0	46
52	Die Hard	6.2	42

Season 13 (2020)

6.42 avg 52 episodes 4.7 → 6.2 28 min avg

Season 13 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker	4.7	79
2	Prequels Better Than the New Trilogy?	6.6	62
3	Beverly Hills Chihuahua	6.9	60
4	Are Films Becoming Game Patches?	7.0	53
5	Con Air	6.7	43
6	Duckman	6.4	41
7	Supergirl	7.4	55
8	Should We Stop Method Acting?	7.3	49
9	Spider-Man	5.1	80
10	Spider-Man 2	5.8	61
11	Spider-Man 3	6.0	59
12	The Amazing Spider-Man	6.4	58
13	The Amazing Spider-Man 2	6.4	58
14	Trolls	7.6	45
15	Dolittle	7.3	52
16	Frozen 2	7.7	51
17	Independence Day: Resurgence	6.6	44
18	CG vs. Hand Drawn Animation	7.1	52
19	Critters	6.0	32
20	Alpha and Omega	6.2	35
21	Avatar	6.8	61
22	Stuart Little 2	5.5	40
23	Superman Returns	5.8	37
24	Totally Spies: The Movie	5.4	31
25	Elektra	5.7	36
26	Alita: Battle Angel	6.1	41
27	Mouse Hunt	6.1	37
28	Battleship	6.1	36
29	The Hunchback of Notre Dame	6.8	43
30	The Lion King (2019)	7.1	57
31	The Adventures of Elmo in Grouchland	6.7	42
32	The Animated Lord of the Rings	6.9	39
33	The Iron Giant	6.2	31
34	The Bill & Ted Movies	5.9	27
35	Mulan	6.0	36
36	Playing with Fire	7.9	43
37	Problem Child	6.8	33
38	Pokémon: Detective Pikachu	5.7	33
39	X-Men: Apocalypse	6.2	31
40	The Lost Boys	6.3	26
41	The Stand	5.8	29
42	The Witches	6.2	28
43	Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark	5.9	26
44	Tusk	6.3	41
45	Curse of the Commercials	7.8	43
46	The Lion King II: Simba's Pride	5.9	33
47	Sucker Punch	6.4	33
48	Krampus	5.9	30
49	The Muppet Christmas Carol	6.6	38
50	Deck the Halls	6.4	37
51	Batman Returns	7.4	41
52	Home Alone 4	6.2	56

Season 14 (2021)

6.41 avg 49 episodes 5.7 → 7.1 26 min avg

Season 14 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Shark Tale	5.7	43
2	The FREAKIEST Raggedy Ann Movie	5.7	27
3	The Mummy Returns	5.8	39
4	Career Dive: Jim Carrey	7.3	35
5	Batman vs. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles	5.9	36
6	9	6.3	35
7	Strange Magic	6.7	35
8	The Terminator	5.9	36
9	Terminator 2: Judgment Day	6.7	39
10	Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines	5.6	30
11	Terminator Salvation	5.2	31
12	Terminator Genisys	5.7	32
13	Terminator: Dark Fate	6.0	30
14	Career Dive: Danny DeVito	7.1	35
15	Wonder Woman 1984	7.4	36
16	Freaked	6.0	29
17	The Prince of Egypt	6.2	26
18	Blade: Trinity	6.5	28
19	Mulan (2020)	6.7	34
20	Julie Taymor	7.6	28
21	Tom and Jerry (2021)	6.4	31
22	Scooby-Doo! Curse of the Lake Monster	6.1	28
23	Who Framed Roger Rabbit	7.7	37
24	The Banana Splits Movie	6.0	25
25	Ready Player One	6.7	27
26	Men in Black II	6.3	27
27	An American Tail	6.2	25
28	Monty Python's The Meaning of Life	6.5	26
29	Cats	7.9	36
30	Jetsons: The Movie	5.7	24
31	Atlantis: The Lost Empire	6.4	25
32	Mystery Men	5.8	20
33	X-Men: Dark Phoenix	6.1	19
34	Cinderella III: A Twist in Time	6.6	28
35	Top 11 Movies Saved by the Ending	6.7	25
36	The Mask	7.0	30
37	The Nightmare Before Christmas	7.1	28
38	The Ring	5.6	17
39	Scooby Doo and the Witch's Ghost	6.3	22
40	The Lawnmower Man	5.6	24
41	Leap!	7.0	26
42	Space Jam: A New Legacy	6.4	25
43	A Series of Unfortunate Events	6.6	22
44	Commercials Resurrection	7.8	31
45	Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas	6.0	24
46	The Polar Express	6.7	29
47	Home Alone: The Holiday Heist	5.9	23
48	Grumpy Cat's Worst Christmas Ever	5.8	23
49	Reindeer Games	7.1	21

Season 15 (2022)

6.40 avg 52 episodes 6.5 → 5.9 25 min avg

Rollercoaster

Season 15 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Old	6.5	31
2	Birds of Prey	6.2	25
3	Rango	6.7	44
4	Daphne & Velma	6.1	25
5	Pan	5.6	24
6	Tarzan	6.9	27
7	National Treasure	6.2	23
8	Return to Oz	7.0	26
9	Batman Begins	6.8	36
10	The Dark Knight	7.6	37
11	The Dark Knight Rises	7.1	34
12	Batman (1989)	7.4	29
13	Batman: Mask of the Phantasm	6.8	27
14	Hancock	6.4	23
15	Bobbleheads: The Movie	6.7	25
16	Lilo & Stitch	7.1	24
17	Pinocchio: A True Story	7.1	31
18	The Rugrats Movie	6.1	19
19	Spider-Man: No Way Home	6.6	27
20	The Brave Little Toaster	6.1	26
21	Tombstone	6.1	21
22	The Fifth Element	6.3	22
23	Garfield and Friends	5.9	17
24	Legend of the Guardians	5.2	17
25	The Batman	6.7	28
26	The Addams Family Movies	6.2	24
27	The Secret of NIMH	6.7	19
28	The Austin Powers Movies	6.4	26
29	Morbius	6.2	28
30	The Shrek Movies	6.8	30
31	Brave	5.8	22
32	Willy's Wonderland	5.8	20
33	Diary of a Wimpy Kid	5.8	25
34	The Kung Fu Panda Movies	6.3	25
35	The Matrix Resurrections	5.9	20
36	Beetlejuice	6.8	23
37	Jurassic World Dominion	6.1	24
38	Back to the Future Movies	5.8	22
39	The Princess and the Frog	6.2	19
40	Hotel Transylvania Movies	6.0	23
41	The Frighteners	5.5	18
42	The Munsters (2022)	5.6	19
43	The Mist	5.9	22
44	Jimmy Neutron: Boy Genius	7.4	22
45	Anastasia	6.3	21
46	Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs	6.2	23
47	Commercials H20	7.9	21
48	Hoodwinked	6.7	22
49	Elf	6.5	19
50	A Christmas Carol (2009)	6.1	22
51	A Garfield Christmas	6.6	21
52	Home Sweet Home Alone	5.9	20

Season 16 (2023)

6.25 avg 51 episodes 5.9 → 6.4 26 min avg

Season 16 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	The Ant Bully	5.9	22
2	The Sword in the Stone	6.1	20
3	Charlie's Angels (2000)	5.4	21
4	The Twilight Saga	6.1	25
5	Click	6.2	21
6	Zathura: A Space Adventure	5.8	17
7	Iron Man	6.7	20
8	Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl	6.1	22
9	Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest	5.3	21
10	Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End	5.5	21
11	Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides	5.6	21
12	Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales	5.3	19
13	Despicable Me and Minions Movies	5.7	16
14	Puss in Boots: The Last Wish	7.1	17
15	Top 11 Disney Remakes That Could Work	5.7	17
16	The Simpsons Movie	6.7	26
17	Beethoven	6.4	19
18	M3gan	5.4	21
19	Cartoon Network Bumpers	6.3	17
20	The Little Mermaid (1989)	6.6	18
21	Dudley Do-Right	6.2	20
22	Kids WB	7.0	16
23	White Chicks	6.8	21
24	Baby's Day Out	5.7	21
25	South Park Movie	7.0	25
26	The SpongeBob Movie	6.9	20
27	The Great Mouse Detective	6.2	19
28	The Super Mario Bros Movie	6.0	21
29	Bean	6.4	19
30	The Truman Show	6.7	22
31	Beavis and Butt-Head Do America	6.8	19
32	Top 11 Tom and Jerry Episodes	6.2	20
33	The Three Stooges Movie	6.1	16
34	The Road to El Dorado	5.2	18
35	The Pee-Wee Movies	5.9	16
36	Robin Hood (1973)	6.5	19
37	Liar Liar	7.1	26
38	The Flash	6.2	19
39	Monster House	6.5	23
40	Coraline	6.3	21
41	Trick 'r Treat	6.2	17
42	Stephen King's Thinner	6.1	22
43	Peter Pan (2003)	6.0	19
44	The Little Mermaid (2023)	6.5	23
45	Mrs. Doubtfire	6.4	22
46	Kingdom of the Commercials	7.9	17
47	Home Alone	7.0	18
48	Edward Scissorhands	6.1	20
49	Tom and Jerry: A Nutcracker Tale	5.8	17
50	Wakko's Wish	6.8	16
51	A Christmas Story	6.4	16

Season 17 (2024)

6.23 avg 49 episodes 6.3 → 6.7 23 min avg

Season 17 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	On Deadly Ground	6.3	22
2	Fat Albert	5.9	19
3	Aladdin (1992)	6.1	23
4	Top 11 Funniest Disney Villains	5.8	19
5	Kung Pow: Enter the Fist	5.6	24
6	Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse	6.5	18
7	Jumanji	6.0	18
8	Superman	6.7	19
9	Superman II	6.7	19
10	Superman III	6.5	21
11	The Snyder Cut	6.6	21
12	Top 11 Poorly Aged Bill Cosby Commercials	5.6	25
13	Galaxy Quest	6.5	18
14	Wish	6.1	24
15	The Land Before Time	6.4	20
16	DragonHeart	6.1	21
17	Happy Feet	6.1	21
18	I, Robot	5.8	21
19	War of the Worlds (2005)	6.0	19
20	Madame Web	6.3	21
21	Return to Neverland	6.1	15
22	The Princess Bride	5.9	16
23	Why is Joshua and the Promised Land?	6.1	20
24	Was I wrong about Treasure Planet?	6.0	15
25	Is Dumb and Dumber Actually Smart or Just Dumb?	6.4	16
26	Is The Incredibles Still the BEST Fantastic 4?	6.6	14
27	Flushed Away	5.9	16
28	Disaster Movie	5.6	19
29	Charlotte's Web (2006)	5.8	15
30	Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny	5.8	19
31	Megamind	6.2	15
32	A Bug's Life	6.3	14
33	Superhero Movie	6.6	14
34	Ghostbusters	6.9	14
35	Rookie of the Year	5.9	10
36	Kindergarten Cop	6.7	13
37	Killer Klowns from Outer Space	6.3	14
38	ParaNorman	6.8	15
39	Sleepaway Camp	6.8	12
40	Hollow Man	6.2	14
41	Ronald McDonald Scared Silly	5.4	14
42	Logan	6.6	12
43	Borderlands	6.1	14
44	Season of the Commercials	7.0	12
45	Meet the Spartans	5.9	17
46	Paddington	6.6	11
47	Rise of the Guardians	6.4	15
48	Barbie in the Nutcracker	6.3	14
49	Gremlins	6.7	14

Season 18 (2025)

6.50 avg 51 episodes 6.3 → 6.9 23 min avg

Season 18 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Snow Day	6.3	12
2	Trap	6.9	15
3	The Punisher (2004)	6.5	13
4	The Tale of Despereaux	6.3	15
5	Beauty and the Beast (1991)	6.7	13
6	The Simpsons Arcade Game	6.4	13
7	Big Momma's House	6.2	13
8	The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring	5.7	15
9	The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers	6.2	15
10	The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King	6.5	15
11	The Hobbit Movies	5.7	15
12	Toy Story	6.5	15
13	Kids Guide to the Internet	5.7	13
14	Kraven the Hunter	6.8	13
15	Willow	6.5	13
16	Stargate	6.2	12
17	Spy Kids	6.5	13
18	Bee Movie	6.6	14
19	Bruce Almighty	6.2	14
20	The Emperor's New Groove	6.4	15
21	Agent Cody Banks	6.5	13
22	How to Train Your Dragon	6.8	14
23	Epic Movie	6.5	20
24	International Commercials	8.2	17
25	Barnyard	6.8	14
26	Pokémon: The First Movie (Review Revisit)	6.6	12
27	Sky High	6.3	11
28	A Minecraft Movie	6.2	13
29	The Hot Chick	6.7	11
30	The Garfield Movie	6.8	12
31	Night at the Museum	6.6	15
32	Spaceballs	6.6	11
33	Scoob!	6.4	12
34	Snow White (2025)	5.9	14
35	Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1990)	6.7	11
36	The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe	6.4	12
37	Antz	6.5	12
38	Corpse Bride	6.3	12
39	Top 11 Simpsons Halloween Specials	6.8	13
40	Tremors	7.0	11
41	The Monkey	6.2	9
42	Goosebumps (2015)	6.2	11
43	Jurassic World: Rebirth	6.2	9
44	Lilo & Stitch (2025)	6.1	11
45	Charlie and the Chocolate Factory	6.6	14
46	Commercials Strikes Again	7.7	12
47	Miracle on 34th Street (1994)	6.1	11
48	The Santa Clause	6.1	10
49	The Simpsons Christmas Special	6.5	13
50	Brazil	7.4	13
51	Surviving Christmas	6.9	8

Season 19 (2026)

6.71 avg 18 episodes 6.5 → 6.7 24 min avg

Season 19 episodes — IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Dennis the Menace	6.5	13
2	The Borrowers	6.1	11
3	The Sandlot	6.8	10
4	Star Kid	6.2	10
5	Muppet Treasure Island	6.3	12
6	Toy Story 2	7.2	15
7	The Avengers (2012)	6.7	11
8	Avengers: Age of Ultron	6.7	10
9	Avengers: Infinity War	6.8	11
10	Avengers: Endgame	6.6	11
11	Superman (2025)	6.3	8
12	Rat Race	7.5	11
13	International Commercials 2	7.9	10
14	Not Another Teen Movie	6.0	9
15	Resident Evil (2002)	7.2	7
16	The Return of Jafar	6.3	7
17	Men in Black	7.0	9
18	Spy Kids 2: Island of Lost Dreams	6.7	9

The Nostalgia Critic (2007)

Seasons