Seasons
Season 1 episodes — IMDb ratings
| # | Title | Rating | Votes |
|---|
| 1 | A Piece of the Action | 7.5 | 905 |
| 2 | Don't Look Behind You | 6.9 | 838 |
| 3 | Night of the Owl | 7.0 | 636 |
| 4 | I Saw the Whole Thing | 7.5 | 813 |
| 5 | Captive Audience | 7.6 | 719 |
| 6 | Final Vow | 7.3 | 580 |
| 7 | Annabel | 7.4 | 642 |
| 8 | House Guest | 7.5 | 612 |
| 9 | The Black Curtain | 7.1 | 609 |
| 10 | Day of Reckoning | 7.2 | 530 |
| 11 | Ride the Nightmare | 7.2 | 567 |
| 12 | Hangover | 7.1 | 626 |
| 13 | Bonfire | 6.7 | 520 |
| 14 | The Tender Poisoner | 7.1 | 496 |
| 15 | The Thirty-First of February | 7.5 | 559 |
| 16 | What Really Happened | 7.1 | 535 |
| 17 | Forecast: Low Clouds and Coastal Fog | 7.6 | 614 |
| 18 | A Tangled Web | 6.8 | 570 |
| 19 | To Catch a Butterfly | 7.6 | 598 |
| 20 | The Paragon | 7.3 | 604 |
| 21 | I'll Be Judge - I'll Be Jury | 6.6 | 478 |
| 22 | Diagnosis: Danger | 6.9 | 462 |
| 23 | The Lonely Hours | 7.7 | 542 |
| 24 | The Star Juror | 7.4 | 538 |
| 25 | The Long Silence | 7.9 | 557 |
| 26 | An Out for Oscar | 7.4 | 482 |
| 27 | Death and the Joyful Woman | 6.6 | 460 |
| 28 | Last Seen Wearing Blue Jeans | 7.3 | 578 |
| 29 | The Dark Pool | 7.0 | 455 |
| 30 | Dear Uncle George | 7.5 | 500 |
| 31 | Run for Doom | 7.5 | 549 |
| 32 | Death of a Cop | 7.4 | 450 |
Season 2 episodes — IMDb ratings
| # | Title | Rating | Votes |
|---|
| 1 | A Home Away from Home | 8.2 | 683 |
| 2 | A Nice Touch | 6.3 | 500 |
| 3 | Terror at Northfield | 7.5 | 534 |
| 4 | You'll Be the Death of Me | 6.7 | 498 |
| 5 | Blood Bargain | 7.5 | 477 |
| 6 | Nothing Ever Happens in Linvale | 8.4 | 697 |
| 7 | Starring the Defense | 6.4 | 419 |
| 8 | The Cadaver | 7.2 | 509 |
| 9 | The Dividing Wall | 6.9 | 462 |
| 10 | Good-Bye, George | 7.4 | 478 |
| 11 | How to Get Rid of Your Wife | 8.0 | 580 |
| 12 | Three Wives Too Many | 7.6 | 566 |
| 13 | The Magic Shop | 7.7 | 630 |
| 14 | Beyond the Sea of Death | 6.9 | 467 |
| 15 | Night Caller | 7.6 | 562 |
| 16 | The Evil of Adelaide Winters | 7.3 | 471 |
| 17 | The Jar | 8.1 | 898 |
| 18 | Final Escape | 7.9 | 630 |
| 19 | Murder Case | 7.3 | 503 |
| 20 | Anyone for Murder? | 6.9 | 421 |
| 21 | Beast in View | 6.9 | 468 |
| 22 | Behind the Locked Door | 7.9 | 577 |
| 23 | A Matter of Murder | 7.7 | 505 |
| 24 | The Gentleman Caller | 7.2 | 449 |
| 25 | The Ordeal of Mrs. Snow | 7.5 | 468 |
| 26 | Ten Minutes from Now | 6.7 | 413 |
| 27 | The Sign of Satan | 6.7 | 525 |
| 28 | Who Needs an Enemy? | 7.2 | 428 |
| 29 | Bed of Roses | 8.1 | 518 |
| 30 | The Second Verdict | 7.2 | 432 |
| 31 | Isabel | 7.3 | 489 |
| 32 | Body in the Barn | 7.7 | 506 |
Season 3 episodes — IMDb ratings
| # | Title | Rating | Votes |
|---|
| 1 | Return of Verge Likens | 8.2 | 584 |
| 2 | Change of Address | 7.3 | 482 |
| 3 | Water's Edge | 7.7 | 518 |
| 4 | The Life Work of Juan Diaz | 6.6 | 434 |
| 5 | See the Monkey Dance | 7.4 | 467 |
| 6 | Lonely Place | 8.1 | 626 |
| 7 | The McGregor Affair | 6.1 | 418 |
| 8 | Misadventure | 6.7 | 446 |
| 9 | Triumph | 6.1 | 427 |
| 10 | Memo from Purgatory | 7.4 | 558 |
| 11 | Consider Her Ways | 7.8 | 534 |
| 12 | Crimson Witness | 6.7 | 451 |
| 13 | Where the Woodbine Twineth | 7.8 | 636 |
| 14 | Final Performance | 7.0 | 476 |
| 15 | Thanatos Palace Hotel | 6.4 | 405 |
| 16 | One of the Family | 7.2 | 462 |
| 17 | An Unlocked Window | 8.5 | 1,061 |
| 18 | The Trap | 7.7 | 495 |
| 19 | Wally the Beard | 7.5 | 434 |
| 20 | Death Scene | 7.8 | 514 |
| 21 | The Photographer and the Undertaker | 7.1 | 420 |
| 22 | Thou Still Unravished Bride | 5.8 | 430 |
| 23 | Completely Foolproof | 6.6 | 388 |
| 24 | Power of Attorney | 7.9 | 480 |
| 25 | The World's Oldest Motive | 7.5 | 426 |
| 26 | The Monkey's Paw--A Retelling | 6.0 | 454 |
| 27 | The Second Wife | 7.7 | 508 |
| 28 | Night Fever | 8.0 | 503 |
| 29 | Off Season | 7.3 | 435 |
