Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2025)

Name: Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
Genre: Mystery
Rating: 6.4
Cast: Galadriel Stineman, Denise Gossett, Kevin Joy, Lance E. Nichols, Ryan O'Quinn

Mystery

After a breakup, Cheryl takes over an Amish gift shop in Sugarcreek. Strange stuffed animals, a kidnapping, and hidden feuds force her, Naomi, and Levi into a thrilling search.

IMDb rating: 6.4 (196 votes)
Episode average: 7.7 +1.3 vs IMDb
Seasons: 1
Language: EN
Type: TV series

Rating trend: this show's seasons do not settle into one shape. Rising Shows ranks whole shows by the shape of their rating trend rather than one average score, which is how you find a show that got better rather than a show that started well.

Browse shows by rating shape → Open in Rising Shows app → View on IMDb

Ratings refreshed Oct 3, 2026 · 1 season indexed

Cast

Seasons

Season 1 (2026)

7.74 avg 8 episodes 7.4 → 8.2 44 min avg

Season 1 episodes - IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	The buggy before the horse	7.4	39
2	A season of secrets	7.4	30
3	Oh little town of Sugarcreek	7.8	28
4	Off the Beaten Path	7.5	24
5	Simply Vanished	7.7	23
6	Stitch in time	8.3	24
7	Mason Jar Mayhem	7.6	19
8	When there's a will	8.2	19