Fear Thy Neighbor (2014)

Action · Crime · Documentary

These are the terrifying tales of the unwanted neighbors who turn home sweet home into home sweet hell. A look inside the lives of horrific neighborly disputes and what happens when a simple issue turns into the worst night of a family's life. Do you really know who lives next door? This true-crime series tells the chilling tales of those with the misfortune to unwittingly take up residence within a stone’s throw of a psycho or killer.

IMDb rating: 7.6 (1,306 votes)
Episode average: 6.8 -0.8 vs IMDb
Seasons: 9
Streaming (US): HBO Max
Language: EN
Type: TV series

U-shaped trajectory: strong first and last seasons, a sag between. Rising Shows ranks whole shows by the shape of their rating trend rather than one average score, which is how you find a show that got better rather than a show that started well. See every U-shaped show in the explorer →

Browse all U-shaped shows in the explorer → Open in Rising Shows app → View on IMDb

Ratings refreshed Oct 3, 2026 · 9 seasons indexed

Cast

Tish Iceton Narrator (voice)

Seasons

Season 1 (2014)

7.23 avg 6 episodes 7.1 → 6.8 44 min avg

Season 1 episodes - IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Lies, Lawns, and Murder	7.1	74
2	Red Picket Fences	7.7	62
3	Final Notice	7.4	55
4	There's No Place Like Hell	7.4	54
5	Home Is Where the Hearse Is	7.0	38
6	Welcome to Murder Street	6.8	40

Season 2 (2015)

7.04 avg 14 episodes 7.0 → 6.3 43 min avg

Bad finale

Season 2 episodes - IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Kill Thy Neighbor	7.0	35
2	Lake of Madness	7.1	34
3	Driveway of Death	7.4	33
4	Good Fences Make Dead Neighbors	7.0	32
5	There Bleeds the Neighborhood	6.8	29
6	Death by Neighbor	7.0	27
7	Home Bloody Home	7.1	27
8	Kill-De-Sac	7.2	30
9	My House My Revenge	6.7	29
10	Next Door to Crazy	7.4	38
11	Homeowner Hell	7.1	29
12	Landlord Death Lord	7.2	14
13	Fatal Family Feud	7.2	31
14	Hitman in Paradise	6.3	9

Season 3 (2016)

6.65 avg 10 episodes 6.4 → 6.0 43 min avg

Season 3 episodes - IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Nail in the Coffin	6.4	35
2	Hell Hounds	6.5	34
3	Neighborhood Madhouse	6.3	33
4	Tunnel of Hate	6.8	40
5	Burn Neighbor, Burn	5.5	29
6	House of the Rising Gun	5.9	30
7	Daddy's Got a Gun	8.8	43
8	Nightmare Next Door	8.5	46
9	Night of the Machete	5.8	33
10	Fuel for the Fire	6.0	28

Season 4 (2016)

6.77 avg 10 episodes 8.2 → 6.6 42 min avg

Front-loaded

Season 4 episodes - IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Lust to Dust	8.2	42
2	Desperate Times, Deadly Measures	7.0	44
3	Hysteria Lane	6.1	40
4	Feud on the Frontier	8.7	41
5	Pack Mentality	6.3	39
6	Neighbors on a Dead End	5.9	34
7	Bang Goes the Neighborhood	6.0	34
8	Monkey in the Middle	6.5	37
9	Mountain of Madness	6.4	32
10	Boiling Point	6.6	18

Season 5 (2018)

6.39 avg 10 episodes 6.7 → 6.0 42 min avg

Rollercoaster

Season 5 episodes - IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Desperate Houseknives	6.7	42
2	Deadly Duplex	6.4	38
3	Head in The Oven	6.5	38
4	Cock-a-Doodle Dead	6.1	33
5	Roadkill	6.3	35
6	Mistress of Death	6.0	34
7	This Bullet's For You	6.1	30
8	The War Next Door	6.4	33
9	Dead Men Tell No Tales	7.4	10
10	Family Values	6.0	35

Season 6 (2019)

6.32 avg 10 episodes 6.0 → 6.1 43 min avg

Season 6 episodes - IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	A Killer View	6.0	31
2	Game Of Homes	6.0	28
3	House Of Shards	6.3	30
4	Deadly Turn	7.0	34
5	Fireworks On Fury Lane	6.6	32
6	Not In My Yard	6.1	25
7	Screaming Oaks	6.7	34
8	Rural Madness	5.7	29
9	Mailbox Madness	6.7	31
10	Boom Town	6.1	32

Season 7 (2021)

6.39 avg 13 episodes 6.8 → 6.6 42 min avg

Season 7 episodes - IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Hell in Hawaii	6.8	35
2	Im Not Moving	6.5	29
3	Backyard Blood	6.5	33
4	Bloodland	6.3	30
5	The Enemy Upstairs	6.9	34
6	Old Friends, Bad Neighbors	6.4	32
7	What's Mine is Mine	6.4	30
8	Bloodshed on Beattie Street	6.2	32
9	Sour Grapes	5.7	31
10	Fence Face Off	6.2	37
11	Philly Fallout	6.5	29
12	Law and Disorder	6.1	27
13	Sin City Shootout	6.6	34

Season 8 (2022)

7.14 avg 14 episodes 7.1 → 6.9 47 min avg

Season 8 episodes - IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	Blizzard of Blood	7.1	28
2	Appalachian Vendetta	7.4	21
3	The Next Door War	6.6	27
4	Unwelcome to the Neighborhood	7.0	22
5	Other People's Property	6.8	16
6	A Clockwork Killing	7.3	23
7	A Ticking Time Bomb	7.4	27
8	Gone to the Dogs	7.8	39
9	Blood on the Lawn	7.0	26
10	The Filth and the Fury	6.9	21
11	Under Surveillance	7.3	27
12	Hell Bent	7.0	23
13	Inferno of Hate	7.4	21
14	Episode #8.14	6.9	16

Season 9 (2023)

7.32 avg 15 episodes 7.8 → 7.6 43 min avg

Saved best for last

Season 9 episodes - IMDb ratings
#	Title	Rating	Votes
1	The Secret Wife	7.8	24
2	Bullets in the Snow	7.3	32
3	Vendetta in Vegas	7.1	20
4	Commanded to Kill	7.3	21
5	Full Frontal Attack	7.0	21
6	Bones of Contention	7.5	25
7	Hillbilly Holler	7.1	26
8	HOA Hellfire	6.9	23
9	Better Get to Running	7.3	25
10	Poking the Bear	6.8	22
11	Road to Ruin	7.2	18
12	Intimidation Tactics	8.0	15
13	The Mayor	7.3	23
14	Cold Blood Country	7.6	5
17	Get Off My Property	7.6	13

Fear Thy Neighbor (2014)

Cast

Seasons

Shows like this